The Big Muddy Ice Cream Blog

Jack Nicklaus Ice Cream is a relatively new brand obviously with input from golf legend Jack Nicklaus.   Strawberry Lemonade  was the first flavor I tried from this brand and I didn't really like it, however, one of our fellow ice cream instagrammers recommended I try a few other flavors from the brand including Coffee and Donuts. As it happens, Sam's Choice recently discontinued their spectacular Coffee and Donuts ice cream and I've been looking for a replacement and I thought I would test this one out! Jack Nicklaus Coffee and Donuts is The perfect flavor for our coffee shop lovers! Our Coffee and Donuts Ice Cream will awaken your tastes buds any time of the day or night, with a perfect mix of premium coffee-flavored ice cream, cinnamon, sugar and moist chunks of donut. The base was a solid but not great coffee ice cream.  It was a very sweet and creamy coffee flavor.  I prefer a stronger and less sweet base ice cream, but I know there are some non-coff...

Sometimes you buy ice cream because it is so WTF on so many levels.   Jack Nicklaus Ice Cream Strawberry Lemonade certainly fits into this category.  I have so many questions! 1) Why is Jack Nicklaus making ice cream? 2) Is he trying to be the next Paul Newman? 3) Why did Paul Newman decide to start making salad dressings? 4) Do people eat ice cream on a golf course? It seems like it wouldn't be the best golf snack. 5) Is lemonade ice cream any good? 6) Wait. I just read the description and this is sherbet and sorbet not ice cream, so why is it called ice cream? 7) OH MY GOD WHAT IS HAPPENING? Clearly I picked up a pint of this inexplicable ice cream.  Strawberry Lemonade is described as Strawberry sherbet and lemon sorbet. I also want to include the longer description from the website, because it just adds another level of WTF to the whole situation: Jack Nicklaus developed this refreshing treat which was inspired by his wildly popular strawberry le...