Posts

Showing posts with the label Ohio

Graeter's Buckeye Chocolate Chip

Image
I occasionally go to Whole Foods to get a slightly different ice cream selection than the norm.  On a trip this weekend I picked up a pint of Graeter's Buckeye Chocolate Chip described as We pay tribute to our home state's famous Ohio buckeye candy with this flavor's blend of peanut butter, cocoa, peanut butter cookie dough, and our gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips.  Indulge and enjoy! After reading the description I was very excited about this flavor, but after trying it I found it a bit lacking.  In this review, I'll try to give you a good idea of why  I was excited and why I was disappointed. First, the base. This was my first time trying Graeter's chocolate base, and I was excited to see how they executed it.  I would say it was solid, somewhere between average and good.  It was a very milky chocolate, but did not taste cheap. The base itself was ok, but the way it interacted with the mix-ins was a bit of a disappointment.  It wa...

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams: Whiskey & Pecans

Image
Alright. I did it. I spent $9.99 on a pint of ice cream. My dearest reader you'd better appreciate this blog post. However, this is not actually the first time I've bought Jeni's ice cream. A way long time ago when I was a freshman in college, in reality inexperienced in the ways of ice cream and still having an unsophisticated palate. My friend Jess and I bought a pint of Queen City Cayenne and Salty Caramel at North Market. Back in the day, aka 2011, the spicy chocolate and salted caramel crazes that have hit desserts in the last few years, hadn't hit yet. One might even say that Jeni's helped start those trends, or at least they were on the cutting edge of ice cream. When I tried those two flavors, I was in love. I really truly hadn't tasted anything like either of these flavors before. The Queen City Cayenne was so rich and chocolatey and really spicy, too, and the Salty Caramel was ssaaallllty . Jeni's really did impress me back then. Now, I...

Reader Request: Graeter's Cookie Dough

Image
Happy Belated 4th of July Dear Reader! Two days ago, on the 4th, I sampled the second flavor of Graeter's I bought as requested by reader, Sarah! Cookie Dough is just about my favorite flavor of ice cream ever. After how much I enjoyed the Graeter's Strawberry Chip, I had high expectations for this ice cream. Thank you to our wonderful hand model, Madeline. To celebrate the 4th in classic Handschy-Palumbo fashion, we ate burgers/veggie burgers topped with made from scratch guacamole, a watermelon salad, popsicles, and  of course, ice cream. This pint had gotten wedged in the back of our freezer, so when Madeline and I got it out, our ice cream scooping attempts were wildly ineffective. We even waited a few minutes and the ice cream was still very hard. But at this point, we wanted our ice cream NOW so we just muscled it out of the container. So you may be asking, what did the ultimate cookie dough lover think of this flavor? The vanilla base was delightful and pret...

Reader Request: Graeter's Strawberry Chocolate Chip

Image
My friend Sarah requested that The Big Muddy Ice Cream Blog review Graeter's Ice Cream. Madeline already had, but I hadn't, so I took that as an excuse to go buy some. With Graeter's you normally need some excuse or occasion to buy some, because it can be pricey! However, I when I made a quick trip through the Fenton Dierberg's ice cream aisle, I couldn't believe my eyes. The pints of Graeter's were on sale for 2 for $5!!! What a steal. I obviously bought two and had to try really hard not just grab a cart and clean them out of all their Graeter's. One of the pint's I bought was Strawberry Chocolate Chip. Although there is nothing very interesting about strawberry or chocolate chip ice cream, I have never actually seen this pairing before. Which is odd because everybody loves chocolate covered strawberries! More brands should make this flavor. This pint was also a limited edition flavor, so get it before it's gone! So a little bit about Graeter...